I spent some time browsing the lovely brown shades of Nyx Butter Gloss, and settled on Spiked Toffee (cocoa with a subtle rosy undertone) as the best Swiss Miss dupe, at least
Butter Gloss - Maquillage Best Sellers | NYX Professional Makeup
Butter Gloss - Maquillage Best Sellers | NYX Professional Makeup
NYX Professional Makeup - Butter Gloss Ginger Snap | Veepee